HTML

stream121
Product Management :: Product Marketing


Showing posts with label pricing. Show all posts
Showing posts with label pricing. Show all posts

11 February, 2026

How AI changes prices and competitive forces

Nate Jones (about, YouTube channel) is a well-regarded commentator on AI and pontificates daily - do bookmark!

Yesertday's analysis is a whopper - it's a must-listen. 

I agree on lots and lots of points, far too many to mention:
  • Per-seat pricing model struggles when an AI-first world is fully embedded - it's not here now, but it will be. 
  • The threat of AI is enough to make people renegotiate deals (KPMG is the example given)
  • The value of having someone on a retainer to fix 'stuff' when it goes wrong is worth a lot

I disagree on one minor point: that organisations want to have software built that orientates around them and their processes. 

NO! If the business process that the software is managing is NOT a differentiating feature to the organisation, then it wants to adopt moderately good practice (not leading or bleeding edge, just moderately good). 

Why? Because they don't want the risk - middle of the road is just fine. 

So they are quite happy to give up their existing practices and adopt the processes dictated by the software because they know that others have adopted it too. 
No-one ever got fired for buying IBM

Herding vs being a lone sheep is worth a lot - an awful lot - the same amount that got wiped off stocks today? No, much more.

This story continues apace..... 

07 January, 2026

Pricing of AI

 This topic has been a real head scratcher – how do you charge for AI?

  • By consumption (eg by tokens used or by transaction) – and the value of a token isn’t too transparent either
  • By conversation

Salesforce CEO Marc Benioff made a pronouncement in December: per-seat with some fair use limitations (see The Register). 

AI is a significant plank in Salesforce’s strategy. It has made lots of investment in the tech and running AI has costs too of course, so it needs to evidence some return. 

Given that AI is touted to reduce headcount, the fact that Benioff is charging by per-seat might be surprising. However Forrester reports 

55 percent of employers regret laying off workers because of AI. More people in charge of AI investment expect it to increase headcount (57 percent) than to decrease it (15 percent) over the next year.

So Salesforce is signalling that AI is an enabler for employees rather than a separate profit centre. This decision is a balance between: 

  • User-based pricing. AI is likely to loved (and heavily-used) by a minority
  • Consumption-based pricing. This is kinda an open-book charging mechanism and the boys in Finance have no control on how big a bill employees might be running up.

In the end Salesforce believe understandable pricing outweighs matching cost to benefit, meaning that they’ll make some profit out of some customers and a loss on others. Forrester agrees – see Outcome-Based Pricing Is Coming — Be Ready For It 



17 May, 2021

The huge challenge of Consumption Pricing


Software Pricing Partners pen some excellent thoughts on the merits of consumption pricing as a charging model: It’s Wise to Question the Big Assumption about Consumption Pricing

The key fact is here: 
Perhaps the most important challenge when considering a consumption pricing model is to align the use metric to the value the customer derives from your solution, which can evolve over time.

This is really, REALLY hard to do: there are inevitable edge cases which destroy the cost of the service or value proposition. For example, number of users vs number of active users vs number of concurrent users when users churn frequently. What happens in cyclical businesses or when there are pulses of demand or inactivity and your pricing is based on transactions per month?

Yes, you can squeeze in acceptable use policies that prevent extreme abuse, but customers get (rightly) irritated at the lack of transparency. 

Alternative billing models (eg flat rate pricing / all you can eat) makes it easier to accommodate some of these challenges, but all models have their strengths and limitations. And that's the key conclusion to draw when building pricing models: it isn't easy and ignore fashion!

02 March, 2021

Signs that your Product Pricing Strategy isn’t Working

My thoughts on Software Pricing's blog about the Signs your Pricing Strategy isn't working.

1. A customer base littered with bespoke deals.

The main problem usually encountered is that there isn't (much of) a discounting policy or it isn't adhered to. When I worked at NeuStar, there was a solid discounting policy AND a robust methodology to go beyond it.

"Special deals" had to be approved not by sales management, but by the product board. This mechanism really did account for the revenue / cost / profitability for the whole customer lifecycle.

2. Purchase options that include unlimited, or “all-you-can-eat” use.

Hmm, unlimited deals should be used when the value of the propositions is too complex for the customer and the vendor to justify, but everyone knows there's significant value. Within reason, as long as costs / burden don't torpedo profit margins, it is entirely valid.

Obviously, it is easier to make this decision when the variable cost of more consumption is tiny.

Fair use policies (whether formal or informal) need to be implemented so that costly abuse of unlimited can be contained. For example, 'burst usage' when greater utilisation is permitted but within reason (eg to a limit or within a period).

3. Prices that don’t account for customers’ varied budget cycles.

Simple statement, but the ripple back of this issue can be massive.

Let's say your customers get paid on a project-basis ie on completion of milestones. As a customer, you'd like to pay your suppliers when you get paid. As a vendor, if income can be guaranteed, this may be acceptable.

If however, the revenue is exposed to risk, this may not be acceptable to either party. For example, the construction industry is prone to delays or changes. As a concrete vendor, payment on project completion is unlikely to be acceptable.

In the software sector, does this change how your product is priced (yes!) or delivered (likely) or built (possibly)?

 

4. Enacting pricing changes without modeling the impact on legacy and net new revenues.

Oh, SO important!

A company releases a new product version that is supposed to cannibalise the existing product. They anticipate that all existing customers will diligently glide over to the new product without churn. 

Oh, how wrong! Any change in product or pricing can lead to re-evaluation of the proposition and the possibility of churn. Please see my work for CDK Global for exactly this problem/


5. Complex or confusing pricing

Value-based pricing is great in theory, but if your product has multiple and diverse use cases, then the complexity of pricing appropriately becomes far too difficult to support. As a result of the practical decision to simplify pricing models, your target market may be sliced to a smaller size – never a palatable proposition, but sometimes mandatory to simplify all sorts of problems, not just in sales, but in product development and delivery and branding.

15 May, 2013

Musings from a startup entrepreneur

These insights from a successful, start-up CEO (Dharmesh Shah of Hubspot) on made me nod in agreement and chuckle: Startups: 10 Things MBA Schools Won't Teach You:

I particularly liked the following points - which I paraphrase:

2. Start-ups need to be clear about what they are not doing.
Everyone knows that a business plan is an extremely creative piece of literature that projects lot of results about lots of decisions made in the future. The purpose of writing business plans to primarily to do lots of thinking about scenarios so that when you reach a decision cross roads, some of the factors to be considered might be familiar to the management team - thereby preventing either paralysis or constantly switching strategy.

5. Pricing is discovered in the market
ie in customer conference rooms in pre-sales, in project planning meetings with customers, NOT in Excel in the office!

6. "Every time you add a new product or product option a small part of your company dies"
It just becomes messier on virtually every front! Treat product extensions with caution!

7. Marketing is about more than .... the right shade of blue for your logo.
Oh, the hours that have been spent on colour palettes, the depth of drop shadowing, the size of the font on the slogan underneath the corporate logo. It makes me want to pound the table and cry!

07 February, 2013

Length of phone call drops and texting will decrease

The Register reports that call duration on Vodafone's network has dropped from over 3 minutes to 1 minute 40 seconds (see Mobile phone calls shorter).

Researching this issue further, fixed line voice minutes (not the same as duration obviously) have been cannbalised by the existance of mobile phones - no surprises there.

This interesting bar chart from the Economist from Hanging up - Reports of the death of the phone call are greatly exaggerated.


Notice that voice consumption - regardless of device - is dropping. The Economist's report notes that this decrease is matched by an explosion in texting. In the future, I anticipate that we shall look back and see that voice and texting have been in decline since 2010 as communication via data mushrooms.

See also this from Ofcom's The Communications Market Report from July 2012 from James Thickett, Ofcom's Director of Research:
'Our research reveals that in just a few short years, new technology has fundamentally changed the way that we communicate. Talking face to face or on the phone are no longer the most common ways for us to interact with each other.

'In their place, newer forms of communications are emerging which don't require us to talk to each other especially among younger age groups. This trend is set to continue as technology advances and we move further into the digital age.'In short, the arrival of each new generation of technology impacts incumbent technology and after a short period of innovation and experimentation, users work out the most efficient / optimal new mix of technologies at their disposal.'


The new kid on the block - 4G
I remain concerned about the potential success of 4G - there is the need for the quantity of data being transmitted, but I don't see the need for the speed. And Network operators do need to do a much better job of data pricing. As I have mentioned before (see Orange (at last) has a common sense data plan) unlimited policies provide no upper ceiling and are open to abuse. And abuse by 1% will account for a disproportionate cost of serving that content (ie video!).